Ramachandra, Balaji, Magaravalli, Rangaswamy, and Govindappa: A Paradigm upswing towards the conservative rejuvention of an traumatized tooth: A Case report


The success of endodontic treatment is entirely dependent upon the quality of the thorough debridement of canal and three dimensional obturation. Similarly function and esthetics are dependent upon the prosthetic rehabilitation as conservatively as possible after the endodontic treatment. All clinical steps play a major role in the treatment; however, the aim of the successful endodontic treatment is to control the number of microorganisms during and after endodontic procedures.1

Among the defined treatment protocol, treatment of immature open apex tooth is endodontically challenging procedure, traditionally ‘apexification’ procedure were treated using calcium hydroxide.2 Calcium hydroxide paste was used for inducing an apical barrier.3 However, this has been material of choice since long time but it has certain limitations like increased risk of fracture in teeth treated with apexification.4 So in order to overcome this, new material Mineral Trioxide Aggregate (MTA) has been introduced. Though it showed better clinical acceptance, it has certain limitations like long setting time, technique sensitive, and tooth staining which led to a search for other materials.3 In the following case report, Biodentine was selected for apexification due to its outstanding physical properties like favourable setting time, low solubility, and excellent handling properties.5 Studies have concluded that biodentine showed better results compared with MTA, due to abundant apposition of hydroxyapatite when exposed to tissue fluids. With these superior biological properties, good color stability, low genotoxicity and cytotoxicity, makes biodentine a supreme material of choice in endodontics.6

Case Report

A 13-year-old boy was referred to department of conservative dentistry and endodontics with complaining of broken and discolouration of upper front tooth region. Subjectively patient gave history of fall from bicycle 4 years ago. Clinical examination revealed an Ellis class 3 fracture with right maxillary central incisor. There was no associating pain or tenderness with the involved tooth. On soft tissue examination, probing depths was normal with no mobility to rule out any periodontal pathology. Sensibility tests (Thermal and electrical pulp testing) were carried out with respect to the tooth, which gave negative response. On radiographic examination, reveals a coronal fracture involving the distal pulp horn of right maxillary central incisor. Intraoral periapical radiograph shows the root end had thin radicular walls with apical flaring and periapical radiolucency of 3-4 mm with incomplete root formation. Adjacent tooth maxillary left central incisor had an intact periodontal ligament space and showed complete root formation. Provisional diagnosis was made as ‘chronic apical periodontitis’ with right maxillary central incisor. Based on the diameter of open apex and length of the root, treatment option of apexification was decided. Entire procedure was explained to the patient, patient’s parents and informed consent was taken.

Under the proper clinical measure endodontic treatment was carried out with the local anesthesia of 2% lidocaine with out vasoconstrictor (LOX 2%, NEON) was administered. Access cavity preparation was done under rubber dam isolation and working length was determined by the radiographic method. Instrumentation was limited to the coronal third of the canal to facilitate direct instrument access to the foramen. Canal disinfection was achieved with 2.5% NaOCl and 17% EDTA. Side vented needle was used 2 mm short of the canal terminus for delivering the irrigants. Passive Ultrasonic activation was done using ULTRA X device (Eighteenth). Canal was dried using paper points. Calcium hydroxide intra canal medicament was placed and tooth was temporized with zinc oxide eugenol. Patient was recalled after 1 week.

In the second visit, the disinfection of the canal was carried out under rubber dam isolation. Irrigation with 2.5% sodium hypochlorite solution was carried out with ultrasound activation. Canal was dried using paper points. Intracanal double antibiotic paste consisting of ciprofloxacin and metronidazole was placed and tooth was temporized. Patient was recalled after 1 week.

In the third visit, the temporary filling and cotton pellet were removed from the access cavity under rubber dam. Irrigation with 2.5% sodium hypochlorite solution was carried out with ultrasound activation and was used to remove the double antibiotic paste from the canal. Local anesthesia was accomplished with 2% lidocaine without vasoconstrictor (LOX 2%, NEON). A final irrigation was carried out with 17% EDTA for 1 minute. Paper points were used to dry the canal and small portions of PRF autogenous matrix were introduced at the apical 3rd of the canal and compacted beyond the apex by using hand pluggers. Biodentine was selected as material for apexification. According to manufacture instructions, biodentin was manipulated. Two increments of Biodentine was introduced into the canal with MTA carrier and delicately pushed towards the apex by using calamus pluggers. Few more increments were similarly introduced and compacted till the adequate thickness (> 4 mm) is created at the apex. Apical packing of the material to the root walls was verified in radiographs before complete setting of the material. Back filling of the canal was carried out with warm vertical compaction technique keeping gutta percha 2 – 3mm short from CEJ. Remaining canal orifice was restored with GIC. To overcome the discolouration of the tooth, Microabrasion technique was used.

Figure 1

Apexification with biodentine and PRF: a) Pre operative intraoral periapicalradiograph, b) Rubber dam isolation, c) Working length determination with tooth11, d) Platelet rich fibrin, e) Orthograde packing of PRF and biodentine, f)Master apical cone, g) Obturation radiograph, h) Microabrasion done with tooth11.


Final prosthetic rehabilitation of tooth was planned with endocrown restoration. Tooth preparation was initiated with flat end tapered diamond bur by providing equi gingival butt joint margin around the entire circumference of tooth. Occlusal reduction was done to achieve an inter incisal space of 1.5- 2 mm and depth of pulp cavity was kept 4-5 mm to aid as retention for prosthesis. Impression procedure was carried out in putty wash technique with addition silicone impression material. Endocrown was fabricated with Lithium disilicate (IPS E MAX CAD CAM). Prior to the cementation inner surface of the crown was etched with 5% HF and saline coupling agent was applied. Tooth was etched with 37% phosphoric acid and cementation was done with dual cure resin cement of transparent shade (IVOCLAR).The patient was recalled after 1st, 6th, 12th month for follow up. Subjective and objective examination revealed satisfactory response with adequate periapical healing.

Figure 2

Lithium disilicate based ceramic endocrown prosthesis: i) Tooth preparation labial view, j) Occlusal view of preparation, k) Impression with polyvinyl siloxane putty and lightbody material, l) Intaglio surface ofendocrown, m) Immediate postoperative in labial view, n) Postoperative inpalatal view, o) Immediate post operative radiograph, p) Six months follow upradiograph, q) One year follow up radiograph showing progressive healing.



The major goal of any endodontic therapy is to preserve the normal form and function of the natural dentition. Regenerative procedures of an immature non vital permanent teeth is quite challenging clinically as it needs re-establishing the lost vitality and development of root maturation. In present day, endodontic approach for restoring an infected tooth with incomplete root end development involves either regeneration or apexification.7

Though regeneration approach has overcome the disadvantages of apexification protocol by strengthening roots and increasing root surface area, in the present case the treatment modality of apexification was chosen primarily instead of revascularization because the diameter of the radiographic apical foramen was less than 1.5 mm, which may be challenging to induce bleeding.8 Other criteria for selection of apexification is root length and width of remaining dentinal walls which were satisfactory in the present case.

In endodontic regeneration procedure calcium hydroxide and Triple antibiotic paste are the most commonly used intracanal medicaments. Triple antibiotic paste (TAP) is a mixture of ciprofloxacin, metronidazol and minocycline. Clinically usage of minocycline in TAP had shown tooth discoloration due to which, a double antibiotic paste devoid of minocycline (ciprofloxacin/metronidazole) was popularised. In endodontic regeneration, Double antibiotic paste has been successfully used due to its similar antimicrobial effects against endodontic pathogens.9 Calcium hydroxide material was used for apexification extensively in past century until when mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) was introduced in 1993 which soon became the choice of material for apexification due to its high sealing potential and better biocompatibility. Extensive research showed MTA has capability to stimulate odontoblastic differentiation with high capacity, superior radiopacity, less tissue solubility, alkaline pH, good dimensional stability and antimicrobial activity.10 However, due to its long setting time, technique sensitive and discolouration property had led to development of other substitute materials.11, 12

Biodentine is an alternative biocompatible inorganic non-metallic compound which has clinically wide range of applications in endodontics.13 In the present case Biodentine was chosen over MTA as it bonds chemo-mechanically with tooth with high compressive and flexural strength than MTA. Calcium chloride, a constituent in the liquid composition of Biodentine is responsible for acceleration of the setting reaction. Biodentine sets in 12-15 minutes which is very low when compared to MTA which needs 2 – 3 days for final setting.14, 15

Various materials can be used for the formation of calcific barrier during apexification have been reported in the literature. In this case PRF has been used as an apical matrix membrane was performed as it is a matrix of autologous fibrin, which gets embedded by a large quantity of platelet and leukocyte cytokines during centrifugation. The PRF membrane that is applied in such cases helps in rapid angiogenesis. Most importantly, PRF being a biocompatible material, can be used as matrix for apexification procedures with cases of wide-open apices.16

For discolouration of the tooth, In this present case micro abrasion was chosen instead of bleaching as the patients age was 13. Enamel microabrasion technique is an alternative method to bleaching in removal of intrinsic enamel stains, and also to minimize surface irregularities on enamel. According to Balan et al micro abrasion technique must be considered in removal of intrinsic stains to a certain extent before any restorative procedure, regardless of their dimensions and depths.17

Despite the large number of in-vitro and in-vivo investigations, there is still an enigma regarding the ideal treatment for the restoration of the endodontically treated tooth.18 Rehabilitation of badly mutilated tooth treated with apexification or regenerative procedures is clinically more challenging than restoring a normal endodontically treated tooth. The choice of acquiring retention from the root canal is no longer available due to presence of apical or cervical biocompatible barrier.

Traditional post and core restoration system was not an ideal restoration choice for open apex teeth, as insertion of post in an apexification treated tooth would compromise the apical seal and also would weaken the root structure. Instead, conservative endocrown prosthesis is considered an alternative restoration for the tooth. The intaglio surface of the endocrown, occupying the inside of the pulp chamber, is responsible for the macromechanical retention. 19, 20 Endocrown is a monoblock restoration achieved by combining the intraradicular post, the core, and the crown in one component can reduce number of adhesive interfaces that are prone for debonding.21 According to Biacchi et al, lithium disilicate ceramics have shown greater resistance to compression forces in endocrown restorations, compared with traditional crowns supported on fiber posts. CAD-CAM ceramics such as, lithium disilicate reinforced ceramics, appear to be the best option for anterior tooth endocrown restorations. The lithium disilicate reinforced ceramics have good mechanical strength and esthetically, they appear alike to that of tooth enamel. 22


The combination of PRF as a scaffold and Biodentine™ as a calcific apical barrier used in the present case can be a viable alternative, which may prove as an effective course of action for creating artificial root‑end barriers.

Prosthetic rehabilitation of such immature anterior teeth are very challenging. The development of adhesion in dentistry and greater strength ceramics facilitates fabrication of endocrowns, which can be an good alternative to standard tooth rehabilitation using post and cores. However, fabrication of such endocrown restorations in the anterior teeth can be considered as conservative approach to establish function and esthetics.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest in this paper.

Source of Funding

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.



AA Nasseh J Bahcall A Koch What is endodontic success? How successful is endodontic therapy? Aegis Dent Netw20173831924


A Thomson B Kahler Regenerative endodontics - biologically-based treatment for immature permanent teeth: a case report and review of the literatureAust Dent J20105544465210.1111/j.1834-7819.2010.01268.x


K Vidal G Martin O Lozano M Salas J Trigueros G Aguilar Apical Closure in Apexification: A Review and Case Report of Apexification Treatment of an Immature Permanent Tooth with BiodentineJ Endod2016425730410.1016/j.joen.2016.02.007


G Topçuoğlu HS Topçuoğlu Regenerative Endodontic Therapy in a Single Visit Using Platelet-rich Plasma and Biodentine in Necrotic and Asymptomatic Immature Molar Teeth: A Report of 3 CasesJ Endod20164291344610.1016/j.joen.2016.06.005


N Sinha B Singh S Patil Cone beam-computed topographic evaluation of a central incisor with an open apex and a failed root canal treatment using one-step apexification with Biodentine™: A case reportJ Conserv Dent201417328510.4103/0972-0707.131805


J Camilleri F Sorrentino D Damidot Investigation of the hydration and bioactivity of radiopacified tricalcium silicate cement, Biodentine and MTA AngelusDent Mater20132955809310.1016/j.dental.2013.03.007


S Shabahang Treatment Options: Apexogenesis and ApexificationJ Endod2013393125810.1016/j.joen.2012.11.046


E C Sheehy G J Roberts Use of calcium hydroxide for apical barrier formation and healing in non-vital immature permanent teeth: a reviewBr Dent J19971837241610.1038/sj.bdj.4809477


KW Kim GH Yassen Y Ehrlich K Spolnik JA Platt LJ Windsor The effects of radicular dentine treated with double antibiotic paste and ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid on the attachment and proliferation of dental pulp stem cellsDent Traumatol2015315374910.1111/edt.12181


KC da Silva Modena LC Casas-Apayco MT Atta CA de Souza Costa J Hebling CR Sipert Cytotoxicity and biocompatibility of direct and indirect pulp capping materialsJ Appl Oral Sci 20091765445410.1590/s1678-77572009000600002


J Camilleri Scanning electron microscopic evaluation of the material interface of adjacent layers of dental materialsDent Mater2011278708


AA Eid T Komabayashi E Watanabe T Shiraishi I Watanabe Characterization of the Mineral Trioxide Aggregate–Resin Modified Glass Ionomer Cement Interface in Different Setting ConditionsJ Endod20123881126910.1016/j.joen.2012.04.013


M Pérard JL Clerc F Meary F Pérez S Tricot-Doleux P Pellen-Mussi Spheroid model study comparing the biocompatibility of Biodentine and MTAJ Mater Sci Mater Med201324615273410.1007/s10856-013-4908-3


M Zanini JM Sautier A Berdal S Simon Biodentine Induces Immortalized Murine Pulp Cell Differentiation into Odontoblast-like Cells and Stimulates BiomineralizationJ Endod20123891220610.1016/j.joen.2012.04.018


P Laurent J Camps I About BiodentineTM induces TGF-β1 release from human pulp cells and early dental pulp mineralizationInt Endod J20124554394810.1111/j.1365-2591.2011.01995.x


AM Pawar SM Pawar MG Pawar SR Kokate Retreatment of endodontically failed tooth with wide-open apex using platelet rich fibrin membrane as matrix and an apical plug of Biodentine™Eur J General Dent20154315010.4103/2278-9626.163341


B Balan CM Uthaiah S Narayanan P Mookalamada Monnappa Microabrasion: an effective method for improvement of esthetics in dentistryCase Rep Dent2013201395158910.1155/2013/951589


J W Robbins Restoration of the endodontically treated toothDent Clin North Am200246236784


A Bindl W H Mörmann Clinical evaluation of adhesively placed Cerec endocrowns after 2 years-preliminary resultsJ Adhes Dent1999125565


T N Göhring A O Peters Restoration of endodontically treated teeth without postsAm J Dent20031631318


IC Nagas E Nagas F Egilmez G Ergun P Vallittu L Lassila Fracture load of ceramic crowns supported by some novel anchoring dental systemsActa Odontologica Turcica2017352334010.17214/gaziaot.327867


GR Biacchi RT Basting Comparison of Fracture Strength of Endocrowns and Glass Fiber Post-Retained Conventional CrownsOper Dent 2012372130610.2341/11-105-l


© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 10-03-2021

Accepted : 16-04-2021

Available online : 30-06-2021

View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


PDF File   XML File   ePub File

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI


Article Metrics

Article Access statistics

Viewed: 275

PDF Downloaded: 99

Wiki in hindi