- Received July 04, 2023
- Accepted August 02, 2023
- Publication September 02, 2023
- Visibility 26 Views
- Downloads 1 Downloads
- DOI 10.18231/j.ijce.2023.025
-
CrossMark
- Citation
NiTi rotary system in endodontics – An overview
- Author Details:
-
Asha K *
-
Sheetal Ghivari
-
Madhu Pujar
-
Sameer Sait
Asha K *
Sheetal Ghivari
Madhu Pujar
Sameer Sait
Introduction
Biomechanical preparation is one of the fundamental step in root canal treatment. This can be achieved by proper cleaning and shaping of the root canal, by following Schilder’s biological and mechanical objectives. That is continuous tapering, conical shape with the narrowest crosssectional diameter apically and the widest diameter coronally. In the past few years, various innovations in NiTi have taken place making them more convenient and befitting for all kinds of canal anatomies.
The main aim of this literature is to enlighten the various aspects of NiTi used in endodontics including their evolution, properties, design features, different generations which have revolutionised dentistry.[1] The information review is based on the search information in journals indexed from 2000 in Medline, Scielo, Pubmed with the use of description such as root canal preparation, NiTi alloys, generation of NiTi alloys, mechanical properties and various textbooks.
Evolution – In 1963, a Metallurgical Engineer William Buehlerin introduced Nickel Titanium alloy in Dentistry, it was named as Nitinol [Ni-nickel, Ti- titanium, NOL- Naval Ordnance Laboratory] Ever since, it has revolutionized dentistry.[2] First hand held NiTi endodontic instruments, which were made of orthodontic wire was introduced by Walia, Brantley and Gerstein in 1988 [2] nearly eliminated iatrogenic instrumentation complication. Later these instruments were fabricated by different manufacturing methods, variations in tapers, length, tip size, cutting properties, cross section. Its been almost four decades since their debut, still various changes in design seen considerably and forge in manufacturing and alloy processing.
Metallurgy and mechanical properties of NiTi
Ever since NiTi was introduced it changed the concept of traditional stepback technique to crowndown technique in chemo mechanical preparation of root canal. NiTi is a combination of Nickel alloy (55 wt%) and Titanium alloy (45 wt %) and some amount is substituted by Cobalt(2 wt %). This composition is known as 55 Nitinol. Another type is 60 Nitinol (5% more nickel) but most commonly used is 55 nitinol because of its better shape memory effect.[3]
The lattice organization of NiTi alloys are austenitic, martensitic, intermediate R phase.
Austenitic phase – It is a body centered cubic lattice, stable, also called parent phase. Elastic modulus is 80-90 GPa. It possess superelastic property.[4], [5]
Martensitic phase – It is a hexagonal lattice, unstable, also called daughter phase. Elastic modulus is 30-40 GPa. It possess shape memory property.[4], [5]
Intermediate R phase –It is rhombohedral distorted phase which is formed when transition occurs from austenite to martensitic phase. Elastic modulus is less than martensitic.[4]
Mechanical properties and crystallographic arrangement of the alloy can be altered by temperature and stress. The distinctive feature of NiTi are shape memory, superelasticity, biocompatibility. These features are the reason for popularity of NiTi in clinical dentistry compared to other metals which are less popular. [4], [5]
The shape memory effect, allows NiTi instruments to “memorize” a certain form and return by heating to its original form because of transition between two crystallographic phases: a crystalline phase (called martensitic phase) which is stable below a certain critical temperature, and an austenitic phase that is stable above that critical temperature (critical temperature range is in the range of -50 to 100 degree Celsius). The superelasticity, allows NiTi alloy, when introduced into the canal (austenite phase), upon stress (example: curved canals) it changes to stress induced martensite phase, allows complete recover of strain upto 8% (Thompson 2000). This stress induced martensitic is not stable at the present temperature of the canal, on unloading (removal of instruments from canal) it retransforms to its original shape. [4]
|
|
Austenite |
Martensite |
|
Ultimate tensile strength (MPa) |
800–1500 |
103-1100 |
|
Tensile yield strength (MPa) |
100-800 |
50-300 |
|
Modulus of elasticity (GPa) |
70-110 |
21-69 |
|
Elongation at failure(%) |
1-20 |
Up to 60 |
Various Advances in NiTi Alloy
Conventional NiTi alloy
Consist of 56 wt % Nickel and 44 wt % Titanium. It consist of austenite phase which possess superelastic properties. It is manufactured by grinding process not by twisting or machining. [4], [8]
Disadvantages –It leads to an surface defects, reduced fracture resistance, cutting efficiency.
Examples – first generation NiTi files(Quantec System (Kerr-United States), ProFile (Dentsply Maillefer, Ballaigues, Switzerland), Light speed files (Kerr, Brea, CA, USA),Greater Taper (Dentsply Maillefer). [9]
Electropolishing
Advantages -helps to remove the surface irregularities, cracks. Increase in fracture resistance, cutting efficiency, resistance to corrosion. [4]
Disadvantages- presence of micro fracture (Herold et al 2007).
Examples – second generation NiTi files(Protaper (Dentsply tulsa), K3 system (Sybron Endo-United States), Endosequence (Brasseler, savannah,GA, USA),Biorace (FKG dentaire, Switzerland), RaCe (FKG Dentaire). [4], [9], [10]
M -wire
Introduced in 2007 by Dentsply Tulsa. Objective of M wire is to make more flexible NiTi alloy with enhanced cyclic fatigue resistance. Consist of 55 % nickel, 44% titanium with trace elements of less than 1 wt%. It exist in austenite, small amounts of martensite, R phase at body temperature. [4]
Advantages - resistant to cyclic fatigue, super elasticity, flexibility.
Examples -Third generation NiTi files (HyFlex CM (HyFlex; Coltene Whaledent), K3XF (SybronEndo, Orange, CA), ProFile GT Series X (GTX; Dentsply Tulsa Dental Specialties, Tulsa, OK), ProFile Vortex (Vortex) and Vortex Blue (Dentsply Tulsa), TYPHOON™ Infinite Flex NiTi (TYP CM; Clinician’s Choice Dental Products, New Milford, CT), Twisted Files (SybronEndo) Fourth generation niti files (Reciproc (VDW) and WaveOne (Dentsply Sirona), Self-adjusting file (SAF) (ReDent Nova), Fifth generation NiTi files (Revo-S, One Shape®(Micro-Mega®) ProTaper Next (Dentsply Tulsa Dental /Dentsply Maillefer). [1], [10]
R phase
Also called twisted files introduced by Sybron endo in 2008. It is manufactured by subjecting it to 2 rounds of grinding process followed by twisting. It is an intermediate phase between austenite and martensite.[4]
Advantages -higher resistance to cyclic fatigue, canal centering, flexibility.
Disadvantage – decreased maximum torque compared to M wire.
Example – seventh generation NiTi files [k3 XF, TF adaptive (Sybron endo)]. [1], [10], [11]
CM wire
Thermomechanically treated NiTi alloy introduced in 2010. It exist in mixture of Austenite , Martensite ,small amounts of R phase at room temperature. It doesn’t possess superelastic properties (Zhou et al). [4]
Advantages – greater flexibility, cyclic fatigue resistance, errors during preparation.
Disadvantages – decreased cutting efficiency.
Examples – Hyflex CM (Coltene, Switzerland), Typhoon CM(clinicians choice dental products, USA), ProDesign R and ProDesign logic system (easy dental equipments, Brazil). [10]
Electrical discharge machining (EDM)
Developed from CM wire by Coltene known as Hyflex EDM. The main objective was to overcome the disadvantage of Hyflex CM wire that is to enhance fracture resistance and cutting efficiency. It is produced by noncontact process by electric discharge in electric fluid. It consist of martensitic and less amount of R phase. Absence of austenite formation.[4]
Advantages – enhance fracture resistance, cutting efficiency compared to Hyflex CM and other NiTi instruments.
MAX wire (martensitic, austenitic electropolished file -X).
Introduced by FKG, it consist of both super elasticity and shape memory. These files can be adapted to different root canal morphologies. It changes from martensitic to austenitic phase. [4]
Examples – XP endo finisher (XP -F), XP endo shaper(XP-S), XP endo retreatment (XP -R)
T -wire
Introduced by MicroMega. New generation file system obtained by heat treatment. Main objective is to enhance the flexibility and cyclic fatigue. It has unique cross section with triple helix, that is 2 main cutting edge and 1 secondary cutting edge. Features are similar to single file system. cyclic fatigue resistance of 40% given by manufacturer. Used in complex root canal morphology.[4]
Examples -2 shape file system
C -wire
Introduced by micromega. Based on single file system and manufactured by C wire heat treatment. Enhanced cyclic fatigue resistance, flexibility, canal centering ability and controlled memory. used in complex root canal system. [1], [4]
Examples – One Curve
Gold and blue heat treated NiTi files.
Dentsply Sirona introduced this system in 2012, by repeated heating and cooling resulted in changes in surface colour resulted in formation of titanium oxide layer. In NiTi blue wire alloy, thickness of oxide layer is 60-80 nm and in NiTi gold wire its 100-140 nm. The significance of these is to compensate for loss of hardness during instrumentation. Which has led to Better cyclic fatigue resistance, flexibility, controlled memory. Used in complex root canal morphology. [4], [1], [10]
Examples – Vortex Blue and ProTaper Gold (Dentsply Sirona), Sequence rotary file and X1 Blue file (MK Life, Brazil), Reciproc blue (VDW), WaveOne gold.
|
Taper |
Increase of 2mm diameter from file tip to handle of the file No taper – Quantec, greater taper – profile (constant taper with different apical tip), odd taper - Quantec, orifice shaper, Protaper universal (both varying tip and tapers) |
|
Flute/groove |
Groove on working surface, collects debris out of root canal |
|
Cutting edges |
Working area of the file which cuts root dentin.it is directly proportional to sharpness and angle of incidence. |
|
Land |
It is formed between flutes, which projects from centre of core to tip of the cutting edge axially. Prevents canal transportation |
|
Pitch |
Number of spirals or threads per unit length and measures the distance from one cutting edge to next cutting edge. consists of variable pitch (greater taper files), constant pitch (Profile) |
|
Tip designs |
Tip of instrument, consists of cutting tip (flexmaster), partial cutting tip (ProTaper Universal) and noncutting tip or passive tip (Profile System) |
|
Helix angle |
Angle formed by the cutting edge to long axis of file. It ascertains the cutting efficiency of the file. |
|
Rake angle |
Angle formed by leading edge to the radius of file. It consists of positive rake angle or obtuse (ProTaper, Hero 642, RaCe, k3, Quantec), negative rake angle or acute (Profile), neutral angle (light speed ,GT rotary system) |
|
First generation files |
Rounded noncutting tip, U shaped - radial land, step back technique, crown down technique, fixed taper, negative rake angle |
|
Second generation files |
Based on design of instrument, actively cutting without radial lands (except -k3), multiple tapers, positive rake angle, variable pitch-Mtwo, alternate cutting edge-RaCe |
|
Third generation files |
Based on advancement in alloy, thermomechanical treatment, cyclic fatigue resistance, M wire, R phase, CM wire -blue and gold surface conditioning |
|
Fourth generation files |
Based on different kinematics, reciprocating motion, single file system and single use concept, adaptive motion, reduces working time, instrument fracture, cross contamination. SAF-hollow reciprocating instrument with simultaneous irrigation |
|
Fifth generation files |
Based on changes of instrument design, offset (center of rotation), reduces taper lock and noncontact space for better debris extrusion, swaggering effect. Revo-S - snake like motion, One shape - continuous rotation and cutting action in three zones |
|
Sixth generation files |
Incorporation of engine driven instruments for glide path, innovation in irrigation (SAF, XP finisher) retreatment |
|
Seventh generation files |
Based on new manufacturing process, twisted file, shape setting (TRUshape, XP shaper), electric discharge machining (EDM) |
Precautions to be taken, while using rotary files OR factors to be considered in rotary NiTi file
Instrument factors
Torsional stress - Fracture of NiTi files occurs because of following reasons when instrument tip is larger than the canal shape, taper lock and when operator exerts extravagant pressure on the instrument.
Torque – Torque is a measure of how much force acting on an object cause that objects to rotate. When higher torque values is used, it might lead to instrument locking or fracture and lower torque values leads poor cutting but less fracture is noticed. To prevent this always use lower or equal torque values as given by manufacture. [15]
Speed – speed refers to revolution per minute. cyclic fatigue is inversely proportional to speed.[16] Greater speed leads to lots of disadvantage like canal transportation, breakage of instruments, loss of tactile sensation.
Anatomy of the canal – Greater the curvature of canal, more is the instrument fracture. It is most commonly seen in the apical one third compare to middle and coronal third. [17]
Skill and experience of operator – Undeniably operator experience, skills, techniques in dental procedures can prevent file separation and other iatrogenic errors. Following points to be considered while operating
Always examine the instrument before and after use
Do not use in dry canals
Excessive forces on files to be ignored [17]
Manufacture instruction –It is the key factor to be considered. By following proper instruction given by manufacture like proper torque, speed, frequency of use, conspicuously, all the iatrogenic errors can be avoided.
Sterilization – Most accepted theory is that thermocycling may result in metal fatigue. But there are studies reported that sterilisation doesnot adversely affect the endodontic instruments. still its controversial further studies are required to evaluate the influence on NiTi files. [5], [3]
Corrosion – Earlier body temperature of mouth, saliva (electrolytes) were considered to be reason for corrosion of NiTi alloys. There was no difference was seen in the surface characteristics of NiTi alloy under scanning electron microscope (Edie et al). United States Navy tests found that NiTi had very good corrosion resistance and performed well in marine environment. [5], [3]
Allergy – Nickel was boundlessly used in fashion jewellery and consumer products. It is a common allergen, prevalence of 28.5%. Titanium was considered as no allergy potential but some others suggest allergies exist. Research on titanium allergies is essential. [5], [3], [18]
Conclusion
With advancement of technology major progress in endodontic therapy has taken place, from earlier stainless steel to NiTi rotary file system. An exceptional feature of NiTi that is shape memory, superelasticity has positive impact towards outcome of root canal shaping. With integration of various advances like M wire, CM wire, Max wire, EDM, Gold and Blue coated NiTi files led to improved durability, reliability and clinical performance of treatment. New endodontic files keeps on upgrading in the market since from first generation to current seventh generation. Many variables like mechanical properties, cross section, manufacturing, designs, tapers, cutting edge, tip designs which has also influenced more favourable outcomes in flexibility, fatigue resistance, resistance to fracture.[8], [1], [12]
Conflict of Interest
The author declares no relevant conflict of interest.
Source of Funding
None.
References
- A B Dablanca-Blanco, P Castelo-Baz, R Miguéns-Vila, P Álvarez-Novoa, B Martín-Biedma. Endodontic Rotary Files, What Should an Endodontist Know?. Medicina 2022. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- M Haapasalo, Y Shen. Evolution of nickel–titanium instruments: from past to future. Endod Top 2013. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- JL Gutmann, Y Gao. Alteration in the inherent metallic and surface properties of nickel-titanium root canal instruments to enhance performance, durability and safety: a focused review. Int Endod J 2012. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- MA Baumann. Nickel-titanium: options and challenges. Dent Clin North Am 2004. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- J Zupanc, N Vahdat-Pajouh, E Schäfer. New thermomechanically treated NiTi alloys - a review. Int Endod J 2018. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- S A Thompson. An overview of nickel-titanium alloys used in dentistry. Int Endod J 2000. [Google Scholar]
- SA Khasnis, PP Kar, A Kamal, JD Patil. Rotary science and its impact on instrument separation: A focused review. J Conserv Dent 2018. [Google Scholar]
- I Mihálcz. Fundamental characteristics and design method for nickel-titanium shape memory alloy. Periodica Polytechnica Mech Eng 2001. [Google Scholar]
- G Gavini, MD Santos, CL Caldeira, ME Machado, LG Freire, EF Iglecias. Nickel-titanium instruments in endodontics: a concise review of the state of the art. Braz Oral Res 2018. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- AG Flores, A Pastenes. Evolution of instruments in endodonticsliterature review. Int J Dent Oral Health 2019. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- S Tabassum, K Zafar, F Umer. Nickel-titanium rotary file systems: What’s new?. Eur Endod J 2019. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- F Ferreira, C Adeodato, I Barbosa, LR Aboud, P Scelza, M Zaccaro Scelza, . Movement kinematics and cyclic fatigue of NiTi rotary instruments: a systematic review. Int Endod J 2017. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- B Biradar, MY Moon, Sudharani Biradar, DN Palekar, A Deshpande, Y. Fundamental design features of NiTi instruments;-A Review. Ann Rom Soc Cell Biol 2021. [Google Scholar]
- A Arias, OA Peters. Present status and future directions: Canal shaping. Int Endod J 2022. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- SW Kwak, Y Shen, H Liu, HC Kim, M Haapasalo. Torque generation of the endodontic instruments: A narrative review. Materials 2022. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- V Faus-Matoses, V Faus-Llácer, C Ruiz-Sánchez, S Jaramillo-Vásconez, I Faus-Matoses, B Martín-Biedma. Effect of rotational speed on the resistance of NiTi alloy endodontic rotary files to cyclic fatigue-an in vitro study. J Clin Med 2022. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]
- AA Madarati, DC Watts, AJ Qualtrough. Factors contributing to the separation of endodontic files. Br Dent J 2008. [Google Scholar]
- M Zigante, M Rincic Mlinaric, M Kastelan, V Perkovic, M Trinajstic Zrinski, S Spalj. Symptoms of titanium and nickel allergic sensitization in orthodontic treatment. Prog Orthod 2020. [Google Scholar] [Crossref]